Case Study 3: From Sensory Awareness to Independent Learning — A New Milestone in Level 3 ASD and Echolalia
In continuing my work with my extraordinarily gifted five-year-old student diagnosed with Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) Level 3 and echolalia, I recently observed two fascinating developmental phenomena: an unexpected auditory response during spontaneous piano exploration and a remarkable breakthrough in independent, self-directed learning.
Having previously documented his progression from predominantly echolalic communication toward functional speech, mastery of all 12 major scales, chord inversions, intervals, and music reading, I began questioning whether his increasingly sophisticated musical abilities were accompanied by changes in sensory awareness and behavioral independence.
The first significant change involved his learning environment. I had repeatedly expressed concern regarding his mother’s frequent cell phone use during lessons, as its sounds, videos, and constant accessibility appeared to distract him from our musical activities. I suggested eliminating the phone entirely during instruction and replacing excessive exposure to electronic videos and games at home with educational programming, particularly the original Sesame Street literacy and language segments.
At our next lesson, his mother arrived without her phone and sat quietly on the couch. What followed was extraordinary.
My student spontaneously began exploring the piano. I encouraged him to utilize individual fingers rather than simply striking the keys with his hands. He responded immediately, subsequently gravitating toward his familiar scales, as usual, preferring to play in the lower register.
While laughing and vocalizing, and without any apparent environmental distractions, he suddenly placed his fingers in his ears, seemingly attempting to block or modify perhaps his internal auditory experience.
I immediately wondered whether this previously unobserved behavior represented an emerging form of auditory self-awareness, or sensory regulation. My subsequent research led me to consider several intriguing neurological and behavioral possibilities.
Increased Auditory Awareness: Playing the piano requires simultaneous processing of pitch, volume, vibration, tactile sensation, and physical movement. His spontaneous ear-covering may have reflected heightened attention to these sensations, or it may have been an attempt to regulate their intensity. I also considered whether he might have been responding to internally perceived sounds or musical patterns, although this could not be determined through observation alone. Importantly, he remained engaged with the instrument, rather than abandoning the activity.
Complex Motor-Auditory Integration: Executing scales, intervals, and chords requires coordination between auditory perception, motor planning, and tactile feedback. I questioned whether temporarily reducing auditory stimulation might have helped him manage these competing sensory demands. This possibility was particularly intriguing, given his previous reliance upon repetitive musical patterns, and his subsequent development of increasingly flexible musical expression.
The Transition to Self-Directed Learning: The most remarkable breakthrough occurred shortly afterward. He began playing two of his favorite pieces, both of which he can now read from musical notation. While I briefly consulted information on my own cell phone regarding his unusual auditory response, something unprecedented occurred. Without any prompting whatsoever, for the first time in nearly two years of instruction, he independently turned to the beginning of his music book and began playing through the pages.
Previously, our work in this book had required my active participation, pointing to the notes, guiding his attention, and directing him from one selection to the next. This time, however, he worked independently. He read the music, played the selections, turned to the next page, proceeding to the next piece without requesting or requiring assistance. Even more remarkably, he continued to not only play familiar selections, but instead played new pieces that he had previously adamantly resisted attempting. For the first time, rather than announcing “all done” or seeking access to electronic entertainment, he independently initiated and sustained his own musical activity.
I found this transformation particularly exhilarating and significant. The distinction between following my instructions and voluntarily choosing to continue playing, reading, and exploring musical material independently represents an important behavioral and educational milestone. Although a single session perhaps cannot establish a direct neurological correlation, or prove that removing the cell phone produced these changes in his behavior, the combination of reduced environmental distractions, spontaneous sensory responses, and independent musical initiative certainly warrants further observation.
In my previous case studies, I examined this child’s progression from mechanical musical repetition toward creative exploration, spontaneous communication, and possible emotional self-regulation through specific pitches and intervals. I am now witnessing what may represent another remarkable stage in his development: the transition from externally structured instruction toward internal motivation, independent decision-making, and ownership of his own learning.
An Additional Milestone in Spontaneous Communication
Equally noteworthy is the continued development of his verbal communication through music.
Toward the conclusion of our lessons, I play a series of familiar songs while he sings. When I first began teaching this child nearly two years ago, much of his vocalization was repetitive stimming; and he did not spontaneously initiate conversation. He now actively participates in determining what songs he will sing as I accompany him, typically 4-5 songs each lesson. Further, he independently requests specific songs, for example, when I play “Old MacDonald Had a Farm,” he spontaneously selects which animal he wants incorporated into the next verse, and then produces the corresponding animal sound, demonstrating not only recognition and association, but purposeful verbal participation in a shared musical activity.
What I find particularly meaningful is that he is no longer simply responds to my musical or verbal direction. He is increasingly initiating communication, making choices, and influencing the direction of our interaction. It is my fervent hope that these observations suggest a developing confidence, communicative initiative, and an expanding ability to participate in reciprocal exchanges.
After nearly two years of highly individualized musical instruction, this student can now perform all 12 major scales in the precise sequence of the circle of fifths, execute three-position chords, recognize intervals, and read musical notation. These accomplishments are particularly remarkable in a child of only five years of age. I believe his most recent achievement may be more significant than any individual musical skill. He is beginning to demonstrate the independence and intrinsic motivation to utilize his musical and intellectual abilities entirely on his own.
For the first time, I was not simply teaching him how to learn. I was watching him choose to learn.